Why Did SMCI Crash Today?

In partnership with

The gold standard of business news

Morning Brew is transforming the way working professionals consume business news.

They skip the jargon and lengthy stories, and instead serve up the news impacting your life and career with a hint of wit and humor. This way, you’ll actually enjoy reading the news—and the information sticks.

Best part? Morning Brew’s newsletter is completely free. Sign up in just 10 seconds and if you realize that you prefer long, dense, and boring business news—you can always go back to it.

Join 4.3 Million Readers Now

If you’ve been tracking Super Micro Computer Inc. (SMCI) or hold shares in the company, you may be wondering: Why did SMCI crash today? This dramatic stock drop stems from serious financial reporting delays, an auditor resignation, and looming delisting risks. In this post, we’ll take a deep dive into the reasons behind SMCI’s stock crash, the company’s history with regulatory issues, and what it all means for investors.

Let’s unpack today’s developments in detail to understand what’s really at stake for SMCI and its shareholders.

1. Immediate Cause of the Crash: Delayed Financials and Auditor Resignation

SMCI’s stock plummeted today largely due to a confluence of concerning events. On Tuesday, Super Micro shared that it still couldn’t provide an exact timeline for filing its delayed 10-K annual report, initially due in August 2024. The company now faces pressure from the Nasdaq to submit a compliance plan by November 16, 2024, or risk delisting. Adding fuel to the fire, Super Micro’s auditor, Ernst & Young (EY), resigned, a move that shocked investors and highlighted potential red flags in SMCI’s financial practices.

According to SMCI’s statement, a special committee investigated concerns raised by EY and found no evidence of fraud. However, it did identify issues that need stronger internal controls and governance. EY’s resignation letter expressed unease with the reliability of SMCI’s financial data, stating that it was no longer confident in the management’s representations.

For investors, the delay in financial reporting and EY’s resignation signify deeper issues, leading to uncertainty about Super Micro’s financial stability and the transparency of its operations. Consequently, these doubts prompted a significant sell-off as investors sought to minimize their exposure to what now appears to be a risk-laden stock.

2. Key Reasons Why SMCI Crashed Today

To truly understand why SMCI crashed today, it’s important to look at the contributing factors and broader implications:

• Delayed Financial Reporting: Missing the August 10-K filing deadline raises red flags for regulatory authorities and investors. Companies with delayed reports often face scrutiny regarding their internal financial controls, which can lead to severe reputational damage and even compliance actions. SMCI’s inability to provide an updated timeline further magnifies these concerns.

• Auditor Resignation: EY’s resignation is a significant event. Auditors are responsible for validating the financial accuracy of public companies, and a reputable firm like EY stepping away indicates a possible loss of confidence in SMCI’s financial integrity. This resignation not only amplifies existing doubts but also implies that the company’s financial health may be shakier than it appears.

• Market Reaction: The financial market places high value on trust and transparency. When a trusted entity like EY walks away from an auditing relationship, it sends a ripple effect across investors and the broader market. Investors are often quick to divest in the face of uncertainty, especially when there’s fear that other regulatory or compliance issues may surface.

These factors combined resulted in a sharp decline in SMCI’s stock value, underscoring just how crucial reliable financial reporting and strong governance are to maintaining investor confidence.

3. Potential Consequences: What Happens If SMCI Gets Delisted?

One of the pressing questions now is: what will happen if SMCI is delisted? Nasdaq’s deadline of November 16, 2024, looms large, and failure to submit a compliance plan could lead to SMCI’s removal from the exchange. Here’s what that would mean:

• Shift to Over-the-Counter (OTC) Market: Delisted stocks often move to the OTC market, where liquidity is typically lower, volatility is higher, and transparency is reduced. This shift makes it harder for investors to buy and sell shares, and it can drive the stock price even lower due to limited demand.

• Impact on Institutional Investment: Many institutional investors and funds are restricted from holding OTC stocks. This delisting could lead to a mass exodus of institutional shareholders, exacerbating the downward pressure on SMCI’s stock.

• Potential Dividend Disruption: For dividend investors, delisting can be a troubling sign. Companies that face financial instability or operational uncertainty may cut or eliminate dividends to conserve cash. For SMCI, a delisting could indicate broader financial issues that may impact its dividend payments and disrupt income for shareholders.

• Reputation and Credibility Hit: Companies that undergo delisting face a tarnished reputation, impacting their ability to attract new investors and raising questions about their governance. While SMCI could technically re-list if it resolves these issues, the process can be prolonged and costly, with no guarantees.

4. Not the First Time: SMCI’s History with Delisting

For long-time investors, today’s events may feel eerily familiar. Super Micro was previously delisted in August 2018 due to similar financial reporting delays, remaining off the Nasdaq for nearly two years until it regained compliance in January 2020. At that time, SMCI cited a need to finalize certain information as part of an audit-committee investigation. The prolonged process of completing documentation, coupled with regulatory scrutiny, kept SMCI in limbo, impacting investor sentiment and stock performance.

While the company eventually overcame those hurdles, today’s events echo past issues and raise concerns about whether SMCI has fully addressed its governance and transparency practices. The repeat occurrence suggests that SMCI may have deeper, systemic issues in its financial reporting processes, which could take time and considerable resources to resolve.

For investors, this history highlights the importance of assessing a company’s operational consistency, especially in areas as critical as financial reporting and auditing.

5. Actionable Steps for Investors: Navigating the Uncertainty Around SMCI

For current SMCI shareholders or those interested in the stock, here’s a breakdown of potential strategies to navigate the current uncertainty:

• Hold for Potential Recovery: Super Micro may yet resolve its governance issues, meet Nasdaq requirements, and stabilize. If the company can bring in a credible auditor and meet compliance deadlines, a turnaround may occur, and the stock could recover some of its lost value. Holding is a strategy for investors with a high tolerance for risk who believe in SMCI’s long-term potential.

• Sell on the OTC Market: If SMCI is delisted, it may be traded on the OTC market. Selling in the OTC market offers an exit strategy, albeit with potential downsides like low liquidity and greater volatility. For risk-averse investors, selling upon delisting could be a prudent choice to avoid further losses.

• Tax Loss Harvesting: With today’s crash, investors might consider tax loss harvesting, which allows them to offset capital gains in other areas of their portfolio. This move can provide tax relief and potentially improve portfolio performance by using losses strategically.

• Monitor Dividend Stability: If dividend stability is your priority, evaluate whether SMCI can maintain or increase dividends. Companies facing delisting or financial instability often pause dividends, which can be an early warning sign for investors who rely on income from their investments.

• Stay Informed: Given SMCI’s history and recent developments, investors should stay updated on any statements from the company, Nasdaq, and new auditors (if SMCI successfully appoints one). Timely information will allow investors to make more informed decisions about their holdings.